I will start out by saying, I grew up in a Christian home. My dad was the pastor and praise & worship leader of the church we attended. So fairly speaking, I was under strict rules. Including all my music strictly be by Christian artists. Examples of the artists I was allowed to listen to (Christian artists, that is.) are listed here:
DC Talk
Phil Keaggy
Jon Gibson
Rebecca St. James
Third Day
Tobymac
Tait
Newsboys
Delirious?
Far From Home
Sixpence None The Richer
Sonicflood
and a bunch more.
There was a time in my life...where I was briefly introduced to secular music but covers in such a way they were made Christian. the words changed around to make it "clean" for young children.
Hallelujah Hop was a collection of Christian, clean covers of secular songs. One of them introduced the first Beatles song I remember. "Help, I need somebody! Help! Not just anybody! Help! You know I need someone! Help!" Makes sense, right?
Later on I was told that my parents used to sing Beatles songs to me when I was just a baby. "Golden Slumbers" was one of their favorites. They had a tape that had mellowed down versions of the songs that they would sing to me. From all that I know, this is about most of the secular music I ever got.
Switching over to a different time period, some years after we moved to Virginia, my parents got Sky Angel, a Christian Television network that showed mostly clean tv. (when I say mostly, they sometimes aired things you never thought would end up on there, like Welcome Back, Kotter.) This is where I was introduced to most of the bands I know of today. Some I still listen to. Others I've grown a strong hatred for.
There were two Music television channels.
Spirit Television Network and
TVU Music Television. Spirit was the clean cut artists, Christian contemporary, no screamo or indie artists. They mostly showed the artists I hate. here they are for ya;
Casting Crowns
Jeremy Camp
Chris Tomlin
Third Day
Bethany Dillion
Natalie Grant
Amy Grant
Michael W. Smith
Plus One
Avalon
Building 429
MercyMe
Point of Grace
ZOEgirl
Probably there are some others. but these are the ones that irk me the most. You want to know why? Some just look like the rich ass moms who go sing about how we need to change the world and send food to all these starving kids and yet they have all the money to get the make up they wear and the clothes they wear. Then, (my favorite hatred of them to rant about) is that most of the people we went to church with at one point, LOVED Casting Crowns and some of those others. They not only wore them out on me, they inflicted it on me like it was cool. They kept asking me "Oh why don't you ever listen to something normal like Casting Crowns, they're so good and they love the Lord" and yadah yadah. Seriously, I don't care how much they love the Lord, they are
NOT good artists and maybe I would like them more if you didn't WEAR THEM OUT ON ME.
and my last reason...which is my part of my main topic I'm trying to get to here. None of them are so creative enough that they keep my interest long enough. I know Chris Tomlin does NOT write his own songs. And that worries me. because you'd think that if he is considered an "artist" they would be writing their own songs. Yeah, sure your voice is great, you can glorify the Lord with that but come on. You're only an artist because it's part of the Christian face that people put on. So that you'll look good and supposedly make Christianity itself look good. and rich. and clean. You know, I honestly gave some of you artists a listen awhile back. and even I could see how tired and how, almost unhappy all of them are. They're not creating music. They're being forced into this by the Christian labels. There is no creativity in the Christian music industry. and that is why, it's getting nowhere and the music is getting old and it's all the same. (and to you Christians out there who read this, don't think for a minute that I haven't heard the songs you all listen to these days. Trust me, I've heard, I've seen, I know. I'm not stupid.)
Now...switching back to when I had television...the other channel was
TVU Music Television. This is where I first heard of Copeland. and a long list of other bands. Some were more or less considered Christian Contemporary and others...well, others were not what I expected. Even my parents thought most of the bands on there were NOT Christian. Because of the way they dressed or sang or some of the graphicness in their videos. Here are some examples of the bands on TVU;
Copeland (Indie rock)
Showbread (raw rock/screamo)
As I Lay Dying (metal/screamo)
12 Stones (heavy rock)
Underoath (screamo/metal)
Switchfoot (rock)
Deas Vail (indie rock)
Maylene & The Sons of Disaster (screamo/metal)
Falling Up (techno/rock)
Between The Trees (punk rock/indie rock)
Anberlin (punk rock/indie rock)
Hawk Nelson (punk)
Flyleaf (metal/screamo/rock)
KJ-52 (hip-hop)
and tons more
Now some of these...are questionable. Some you would've never thought they were Christian. And mostly, the music isn't considered Christian. I have heard some bands specify how they did NOT want to be considered a Christian band. Because they write to create music. If someone is lead to Christ by it, then by all means cool but for the most part, they do what they do and do it because it's their art, their trade, they enjoy what they do. They aren't putting on a face for the people. They are
real. Now my parents liked to always talk back and say things like, "Well, spreading the word isn't offensive and if you're really Christian then you would spread the word and not be ashamed." It is not a matter of shame. It is a matter of caring. Some people have chosen the way they are going to go and that's it. They may change their minds later but that's up to them. Not you. So don't press it. Please.
One of the things my parents always thought was very un-Christian was this video of Showbread.
Guys wearing make-up. Nail polish. screaming. Moving their hips, looking suggestive. I remember this one struck out to them because they never thought I would like it. Of course, growing up in a strict family, of course I'll be attracted to some form of rebellion. Of course, now I don't like them as much as I did then but they do rank in my "underground" bands. I met one of my best friends because of them. (I'd also like to point out, that while I'm trying to think up for the next paragraph, I'm rocking out to this song, with my fist in the air. Good times...)
Now things have changed. my parents rules have mellowed out and even when I was still under their rule, I was allowed to listen to new bands. Because of TVU introducing me to new ideas and music and thanks to the internet and my friends I've heard of these bands since...
Fleet Foxes
My Chemical Romance
Foster The People
Gorillaz
Radiohead
The Smiths
Blur
Arctic Monkeys
Michael Jackson (I didn't know who he was till high school.)
The Almost
Anchor & Braille
The River Empires
Sigur Ros
BJork
The Black Keys
Cage The Elephant
The White Stripes
Daft Punk
Doves
Feist
The Kills
Owl City
The Pixies
Regina Spektor
Simon & Garfunkel
She & Him
...and the list goes on and on. and is still going on. always will until I die.
So what I wanted to write this blog to say was...Secular music is creative. There is sound to it. no mask or fake-face. the real deal. it's down to the nitty gritty. and Christians, there are reasons why you're music isn't great. It's not a matter about it being offensive (in some cases, at least not for me really. Not in the sense these songs talk about God.) it's a matter of whether the lyrics get to you or not, in that good way when you can relate. I know of very few Christian people, also artists, who actually can do that. Can make good, creative music and still have some human meaning in the lyrics and still yet some praise. But I am sorry, Chris Tomlin, Casting Crowns...no. never. they are not creative, do not sound that good, and Tomlin doesn't even write his own songs. If you want honest artists, LOOK FOR THEM. No, they are not going to be Christians half the time. But I've found a ton of
real artists with
real passion. that's why I'm so hipster. Because they are underground. Consider them dirty, and I've been digging for this gem in my life, and it's called..."_____" Fill in the blank. Copeland, Fleet Foxes, Foster The People, Radiohead, name some bands that means something to you because they have real lyrics. I have this gem encrusted in my life and how happy I am, thank you.
To put it simply, I think that you can glorify God, even with secular music. Love songs for example. Isn't the church the bride and God the groom and all that? Get down with God to some Marvin Gaye or The Beatles. Even if the artists are or aren't into God or Jesus, they can still glorify God with the music they make because God did give them the talent, therefore we may enjoy it ourselves. It's not a sin to enjoy what God placed on this earth, is it?
Instead of ranting on and on about how I think Christian music basically sucks and that my "underground" music is way better, this is how I'll end it. If you Christians keep thinking my music sucks and then you get offended because I think yours sucks, psht, oh well. How do you think I feel? (Actually I'll be glad you don't like some of the bands I like because you Christians tend to make everything mainstream and I wouldn't want that to happen, hmm?) But it is nice when you come across someone who listens to the same band as you (who doesn't wear it out) and you can say, "Oh, you've heard them too?" Wouldn't it be a satisfying feeling to know that what you were digging for was the most valuable gem in your whole collection? and that you can share these gems with a friend? (and to you Christians, no your music is not a real gem. It's those pieces of plastic they put in fake jewelry for kids. That's how cheap and terrible it is.)
Also, I have nothing against Christians. Just their religious ways. and their music obviously. I'm a Universalist (I believe in God, Jesus, the Holy Ghost and all that. But I don't like being called a Christian. too mainstream.) and I still listen to some of those Christian bands I listened to back then. Every once in awhile. I am very selective on what I listen to now. Ask my friends and they'll tell you I have to be in a certain mood to listen to anything new.
Anywho, just wanted to rant and talk about my thoughts on the whole creativity side to secular music. I hope I made my point clear and that someone will see my side of things.